the difference is real
"Every cookie leaves our kitchen as if it were for our own family table. That's not a policy — it's just who we are."
Caitlyn Dao
1. Fan Favorite
Classic
Peanut Butter Cookies
Thick, chewy centers with that perfect fork-press crosshatch. Made with real peanut butter — the kind that actually tastes like peanuts. Golden on the outside, soft all the way through. The cookie that started it all.
$26
Made fresh
for your pickup date
Per Dozen . 12 Coockies
2. THE CLASSIC
Timeless
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Golden-brown edges, gooey centers, loaded with real chocolate chips. Made with real butter and pure vanilla extract. No shortcuts, no compromises. The gold standard — and we have absolutely no reason to mess with it.
$26
Made fresh
for your pickup date
Per Dozen . 12 Coockies
What Fargo-Moorhead says
Oh Fet Cute!
For real though.
"Ordered two dozen peanut butter cookies for my son's class party and every single one was gone in five minutes. The teacher asked me for the bakery's number. Ten out of ten."
Frankie B.
"Ordered two dozen peanut butter cookies for my son's class party and every single one was gone in five minutes. The teacher asked me for the bakery's number. Ten out of ten."
Frankie B.
"Got a 3-dozen bundle for a baby shower — hit of the entire party. Beautiful, delicious, and Caitlyn was so easy to work with. Already planning my next order."
Jessica R.
Follow Along
Fresh Out of the Oven
Join the community on TikTok and Instagram for behind-the-scenes baking, flavor drops, and unfiltered cookie breaks.
"Ordered two dozen peanut butter cookies for my son's class party and every single one was gone in five minutes. The teacher asked me for the bakery's number. Ten out of ten."
Frankie B.
🎄
Holiday Pre-Orders
Christmas, Valentine's, Easter — limited pre-orders open weeks early. They sell out fast without exception.
"Ordered two dozen peanut butter cookies for my son's class party and every single one was gone in five minutes. The teacher asked me for the bakery's number. Ten out of ten."
Frankie B.
📸
Instagram Drops
New limited flavor announced every Monday on @ohfercutebakedgood. Follow before it's gone.
"Ordered two dozen peanut butter cookies for my son's class party and every single one was gone in five minutes. The teacher asked me for the bakery's number. Ten out of ten."
Frankie B.
📧
Email List
Early access to holiday pre-orders and exclusive bundles. Zero spam — just the good stuff.
"Got a 3-dozen bundle for a baby shower — hit of the entire party. Beautiful, delicious, and Caitlyn was so easy to work with. Already planning my next order."
Jessica R.
👥
Facebook Groups
We're active in Fargo-Moorhead community groups. Share us with your neighborhood!